Last Sunday I met-up with some of the folks associated with the Wave Rowers club near the Bay Bridge on the Maryland side of the Chesapeake Bay.
A few of the members brought a good variety of different open water rowing craft, including Aldens, Echo, Little River Marine, and others. I rowed an Echo out to Love Point, where the Chester River opens up into the Chesapeake Bay, and back.

Chester River Row - 4.16nm Total
My initial impressions of the Echo, as an open water rowing craft, were: 1.) I did not think it tracked very well, and 2.) I was impressed with the self-bailer – I had a bunch of water in my foot well when I launched, but it quickly went out the self-bailer when I got some speed going.
I then hopped in an Alden Star for a quick spin and really liked it. It felt stiff and fast, and the keel helped it keep it’s track very well. It does not come with a self-bailer, though, so I was dubious of rowing this boat in rough water. It seems like it relies on water sloshing itself out of the foot well, which I find a bit annoying. Out of the boats I tried, this one felt the most like a true racing boat.
Finally, another Waver Rower member and I jumped into a Heritage 18 Dory from Little River Marine. I could definitely feel safe in big water in this boat. However, I sat in the bow rowing position and could feel the bow porpoiseing with each stroke we took. It was not bad, it just felt strange to be dipping into the waves instead of rising above them. In addition, the rowing tracks extend 3 or more inches over the fixed rowing seats and you could feel them bend and flex when your seat went near the end of the tracks. It’s also possible I could stand to lose a few pounds…All a bit unnerving. All-in-all, however, a nice boat.
In sum, all of these boats were tried on relatively calm waters, and when the wind kicked-up to near 12 knots later in the afternoon, everyone straggled in to the beach. I was too tired at that point to try these boats in rougher water, but I wish I had now. Personally, I would not take any of these boats across the Chesapeake Bay (at some of her wider points). Nothing against any of them, just a personal preference. I would feel safest in the Heritage 18 Dory for an across-the-Bay trip, but I think rowing with a partner would be a requirement in that boat due to the way she trims, etc. Moreover, all of these boats had fiberglass hulls. The open water purist in me is wanting to experience this type of rowing in a classic wooden boat. For me, a classic wooden rowing boat is sort of feng shui for open water rowing zen.